The personal guarantee is often described as the ultimate incentive alignment tool in SBA-backed search deals. If the buyer has signed for the loan personally, the argument goes, they will never let the business fail. We've heard of examples where that hasn't been the case, especially when things go south.
A PG feels overly risky in a lot of the deals I see, especially for buyers who have built up assets and have a family. So I was glad to sit down with Jason Hunt, founder of Ink, on the latest episode of The SMB Investor podcast. Jason started his career in restructuring during the financial crisis, bought and sold a business, and came back to search years later in a community property state, where his wife's business would have been collateral on the loan.
The guarantee aligns incentives in good times
A guarantor has every reason not to run the business into the ground. While the company is performing, the buyer, the lender and the equity investors all want the same thing: steady cash flow that services the debt and builds value.
That alignment changes in a default. A lender only cares about principal and interest. When a deal goes wrong, the bank looks for recovery, and the guarantor starts to care more about salvaging the guaranteed principal than about anything else. That can mean passing on a hail mary, or on a strategy that might have preserved investor capital, because the guarantor's own balance sheet is now the thing at stake.
For equity investors, that is the moment the guarantee stops working for them. The person running the company may be focused on their own exposure to the bank rather than on the equity.
Takeaway: the PG aligns the buyer with the lender. In good times that is close enough to alignment with equity. In a default it isn't.
Most search deals are asset light
The second problem is what the bank can actually recover. Many search acquisitions are service businesses with few hard assets. A CPA firm with a $3mm loan doesn't have much to liquidate. If it fails, the gap between the loan and what the bank can recover from the business can be most of the loan, and the guarantor is on the hook for that gap.
That is a very different exposure from a guarantee on an equipment-heavy business or a building, where collateral covers a good part of the balance. For an asset-light company, the guarantee is close to a personal guarantee of the full loan.
For more on how SBA acquisition loans perform when things go wrong, see what SBA loan charge-off data shows.
